Resolution over higher Horace Nye bids sparks controversy

The Horace Nye Nursing Home in Elizabethtown.

The Horace Nye Nursing Home in Elizabethtown. Photo by Keith Lobdell.

— As protesters honked, yelled and chanted in front of the Essex County Government Center March 25, the Ways and Means Committee passed a resolution asking three bidders to up their proposals.

The resolution was met with protest inside the county chambers, as some supervisors were concerned over the fact that the three bidders had already submitted their responses before a resolution was passed by a vote of 11-5, with two absent.

County Manager Daniel Palmer said that the new resolution for "best and final offers" would only be open to the firms that had submitted bids to the county: Centers for Specialty Care out of New York City; Gerald Woods CPA, out of Nassau County; and Elliot Management Group out of Rockland County, each of whom submitted a bid for the minimum purchase amount of $4 million.

"This will be open to the three that bid and we are going to ask for the best and final offer," Palmer said, adding that the offers have already come back.

"We went back to the broker (Marcus and Millichap) and said that we are looking for the best and final offer from the three bidders," Palmer said. "They went back to them and each has already responded to the broker."

"How do you go out and request bids when the board has not approved you going out to request bids," Moriah Supervisor Thomas Scozzafava said. "We have a resolution that is going through Ways and Means and then through the full board, and now it is my understanding that we have already received their best and final offer before we have approved that process."

"It was a case where the cart got put before the horse, and sometimes that happens," County Attorney Daniel Manning said. "You pass this, it will be okay. If you do not pass this, then you will go off the $4 million bids."

Vote on this Story by clicking on the Icon


Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment